Customer service, Part 2 the pre-onboarding process

Pre-Onboarding is Not Optional

Why most fitness businesses lose the sale before the trial even starts—and how to fix it.

Let’s call it what it is: most fitness businesses are leaking clients before they ever step foot in the gym.

And it’s not a lead problem.

It’s a conversion problem.

It’s a customer service problem.

It’s a pre-onboarding problem.

If you’re waiting more than four hours to reply to a lead, you’re already in the danger zone. People reach out when their motivation is high—and you’ve got a tiny window before life, anxiety, or self-doubt talks them out of it.

⸻

1. What Happens After That First Contact?

You need a clear, low-friction process for leads. Ask yourself:

• Do they get a warm reply quickly?

• Do they know exactly what happens next?

• Do you offer a phone chat? A tour? A trial class?

• Are you guiding them… or ghosting them?

From first reply to final decision, the sale is happening the entire time—not just in a rushed 45 seconds after class while they’re sweaty, overstimulated, and halfway out the door.

Selling at the wrong time (especially post-class chaos) is not service. It’s pressure. And it’s why people disappear.

⸻

2. Lead Nurture Isn’t About Hype—It’s About Help

People don’t sign up because you said “3 sessions per week.” That’s a feature.

They sign up when you explain that 3 sessions per week =

• Feeling strong walking down the aisle

• Not dreading stairs

• Finally getting through a day without brain fog or back pain

Translate features into real-life benefits. Speak in the language of results they care about—not the one your booking system spits out.

⸻

3. Trial Class ≠ Afterthought

Your trial class should wow them—not wear them out, confuse them, or make them question their decision to come.

That means:

• Don’t sell at the wrong moment (running late, flustered, 10 people behind them waiting for their protein shake)

• Don’t let them leave feeling like a number

• Don’t make them guess where to go, how much to lift, or how to pair up

⸻

4. Programming Cues That Make or Break Trust

Quick tips:

• Ask their experience level before assigning a weight or progression

• Listen when they say what they’re used to—especially if they do know what they’re doing

• Watch for silent goodbyes: if they look disengaged, mismatched, or confused, you may have lost them already

The “you go, I go” style is great if your participants are evenly matched—but it’s hell for a new or underconfident person paired with someone far above or below their level.

Have fallback options ready:

• Time caps per set

• Mini circuit formats

• Rotation cues that let people flow solo if needed

⸻

5. Group Dynamics Can Alienate Half Your Class

If your session format leans on team selection or partner drills, understand this:

Roughly 50% of people are introverts.

And many have gym or school trauma around being picked last or not fitting in.

Don’t leave your groupings to chance.

Create formats that feel inclusive and planned—so people don’t end up stranded and awkward while everyone else is bonding over deadlifts and post-class brunch plans.

⸻

6. Best Welcome I Ever Got (Steal This Format)

At a cycle studio in North America, this is what happened:

• I got a pre-class email explaining everything—what to wear, what to bring, and that nerves were normal

• On arrival, staff came out from behind the desk to greet us and give a tour

• We were told where to put our bags, where the bathrooms were, and what to expect

• Someone personally set up our bikes and checked in on how we were feeling

• And after the class, someone was there to help us decompress, pack up, and point us toward whatever we needed next

I’ve never forgotten it. Why?

Because it made me feel seen. Prepared. Respected.

And because it happened before I even broke a sweat.

This is world-class pre-onboarding. And it didn’t happen by accident.

⸻

7. Post-Trial Follow-Up: The Final Nail (or Win)

If they don’t hear from you the next day, they’ll assume you didn’t notice them—or that they didn’t belong.

Use a personalized follow-up:

• “Hey, how are your legs feeling?”

• “Totally normal to feel a little sore. Here’s how to recover—and why coming back tomorrow will help.”

• “Loved having you in class—here’s your link to book again.”

It sounds simple. It is simple.

But it’s rare.

⸻

8. First Impressions Are Forever

Most people don’t fall in love with fitness on day one.

They fall in love with how you made them feel.

Did they feel guided?

Did they feel welcome?

Did they feel like this could be their place?

If not, they probably won’t come back—no matter how smart your programming is.

⸻

9. You Don’t Need More Leads—You Need Better Conversion

If your numbers are stalling despite a steady stream of leads, you don’t have a visibility issue. You have a conversion leak.

And the best way to fix it?

Fix your pre-onboarding.

Because the second someone clicks “Send” on your contact form, your system needs to be on—dialled, warm, human, and intentional.

⸻

Want help building this into your gym, studio, or PT biz?

We’re here. Drop us a message, and we’ll walk you through it.

You only get one first impression.

Let’s make it unforgettable—for the right reasons.